Collagen vs Whey Protein

Whey protein is a longtime staple of the world of fitness. Popularised by Arnold Schwarzeneger all those years ago, it’s been used by men and women to build muscle strength, especially with the advent of Crossfit. Collagen exploded in popularity relatively recently, appealing to people both in and out of the fitness space. Whey Protein and Collagen are indeed both proteins, but they don’t necessarily have to be pitted against each other and in reality, they complement each other in a nutrition regimen!

Collagen is typically made via bone hide from beef cows however there are vegetarian-friendly versions such as marine collagen. Bovine, Marine, Chicken collagen all contain varying amounts of the common types of collagen – Type 1,2,3. Collagen is primarily heavy in three amino acids – glycine, proline, and hydroxyproline. These amino acids have properties that aid in the health of connective tissue, skin, hair, and nails.

Collagen is a protein that occurs naturally in our bodies. As we age, this production starts to slow and needs supplementation. In addition to Collagen playing a role in the health of hair, skin, and nails, it also has a significant role in the connective tissues such as bones, ligaments, tendons, and the skeletal muscles. 

Whey Protein on the other hand is a protein derived from milk – a nutrient dense complete source. Initial processing produces Whey Protein Concentrate which is 70%-80% protein and contains some lactose. Whey protein isolates undergo an advanced purification process that filters out fat, lactose, sugar, and carbohydrates producing an incredibly healthy 90% protein source. We only stock Whey Protein Isolate so that you get only the best protein available.

Whey Protein is considered to be a complete protein, defined as containing all 9 Essential Amino Acids (EAAs). Other proteins which are aimed at being an alternative to Whey Protein — such as plant proteins — will often have to be supplemented to achieve the same all-in-one balance. Whey Protein’s high levels of BCAAs (valine, leucine, and isoleucine) provide functional components for muscle recovery & retention.

While Whey Protein’s status as a complete protein means it contains all 9 Essential Amino Acids, its notoriety exists with its exceptionally high levels of leucine. Leucine has a unique ability to stimulate muscle protein synthesis. Whey Protein can be a powerful tool to achieve several fitness and wellness goals such as muscle gains, weight management, therapeutic recovery, sarcopenia management and more.

The amino acid profiles of Whey Protein and Collagen are different, and that’s why we suggest not replacing one with the other, but rather supplementing with both if you feel the need for any support for your muscles or joints. 



Related articles

Blog_GD

Introducing Gentle Day feminine hygiene products

Being a woman is one of life’s greatest gifts. Over the course of our lives here at Sally-Ann Creed, we’ve come to cherish the strength, intuition, and deep capacity for nurturing that flows through us all. We carry an innate wisdom in our bodies—a connection to cycles, seasons, and the...
Blog_Constipation

Constipation – the uncomfortable truth

Bowel habits are a crucial indicator of a person’s overall well-being. They can become disturbed when a person is out of their natural environment. In the hospital setting, several factors influence patients’ bowel movements, including changes in diet and fluid intake, reduced mobility, certain medications, psychological stress, and disruptions to...
Blog_US Food

The new Dietary Guidelines for Americans (2025-2030)

“The consequences have been devastating. More than 70% of American adults are overweight or obese. Nearly one in three American adolescents between the ages of 12 and 17 has prediabetes. Diet-driven chronic disease now disqualifies large numbers of young Americans from military service” The new US Dietary Guidelines for Americans...
Blog_Akkermansia2

All about Akkermansia

Gut health is a major focus in modern nutrition science. This is because the gut plays a huge role in your immunity, nutrient absorption, metabolism and communication with the rest of the body. That’s why interest in the gut microbiome has grown so rapidly. Among the trillions of microbes that...
Woman struggling with diverticulitis

What you need to know about Diverticulitis

Most people only hear about diverticulitis when something goes wrong. A scan might show “small pouches” in the bowel or someone goes to emergency with lower-left abdominal pain. But this condition is far more common and far more manageable than many realise. With the right information, you can spot symptoms...
Blog_GlucoGuard

What is GlucoGuard?

GlucoGuard is one of our newest and most exciting products. It was developed through the innovative work of scientists who discovered a unique collagen peptide that helps the body manage blood sugar naturally. It’s completely sugar-free, fat-free and derived as a collagen, yet the science behind it is quite remarkable....